
[Previously: Day 1, Day 2, Day 3, Day 4, Day 5, Day 6]
Yesterday I wrote for 3 hours and 8 minutes.
I’m going to write about bullshit today, and apologies ahead of time to those who are sensitive to base language, but I’m actually intending a very specific usage of the term. In On Bullshit, the American philosopher Harry Frankfurt identifies different groups of people relative to their orientation to the truth when communicating with others. Both honest and dishonest people care about the truth – they are just oriented on opposite sides of it. Bullshitters, however, don’t care if what they say is true or not – they only care if what they are saying is persuasive to their audience. They’ll say whatever they need to (might be true, might not) if it gets them the desired outcome.
Many people other than con men and hucksters try to get away with bullshit. Friends, family – ourselves if we are being honest (wink) – we’ve all tried to convince people of something, whether a big deal or something trivial, regardless of the truth. But because we all hate being bullshitted by someone else (it feels like such a violation of trust!), human beings have evolved a pretty finely tuned sense of when someone is bullshitting us.
Why am I bringing all of this up? Because writing is communicating, so writers need to seriously consider bullshit. Because generally, writers want their stories to “ring true” with audiences. Because convenient plot devices that wrap up the story nicely but don’t fit with the characters or reality you’ve written are bullshit. Because forcing a character to make decisions that go against the characterization you’ve given them just to arrive at some event you want to write about is bullshit.
And readers are better at spotting this bullshit than you think (after all, you’re good at it, aren’t you?), and they generally don’t like it. Be careful how you write, because you might be undermining your own goals of connecting meaningfully with the reader.
Or, if you’re going to bullshit anyway, get really good at it.

The Darn Ecologist

In a 